Designing Your Cake

No matter the celebration, at Jarosch Bakery we work with you to design an outstanding cake from flavor to finish that will delight all your guests.

Cake Options: The Right Size

Whether you are feeding 8 people or 80, we have a multitude of options to fit your needs. When deciding on a size, bear in mind our cake servings are liberally estimated so you’ll get more slices if your guests want “just a sliver.”

Round Cakes have multiple layers of cake and fillings while Sheet Cakes have two layers of cake and one layer of filling, making sheet cakes a bit easier to cut and serve. If you prefer extra layers of flavor combinations, we recommend a round size, but a third layer of cake and second layer of filling are available for sheet cakes at an additional cost.

Round Cake

Size & Servings

  • 8": 8 - 10
  • 9": 12 - 15
  • 10": 20 - 25
  • 12": 25 - 30
  • 14": 30 - 40
  • 16": 45 - 50

2 Layer Sheet Cake

Size & Servings

  • ¼ Pan: 15 - 20
  • ½ Pan: 30 - 42
  • ¾ Pan: 50 - 60
  • Full Pan: 60 - 84


3 Layer Sheet Cake

Size & Servings

  • ¼ Pan: 30
  • ½ Pan: 50
  • ¾ Pan: 70 - 80
  • Full Pan: 100

Cake Options: Fresh Flavors

Experience the difference freshness makes when you order a specialty cake from Jarosch Bakery. Each of our delicate doughs is light, fluffy, and fork tender, containing no additives or preservatives. We follow Grandpa’s original recipes, using the highest quality ingredients in our cakes including eggs, milk, sugar, cake flour, and vegetable shortening. Check out our cake options:

  • Yellow: this buttery and moist cake has a hint of lemon to brighten the flavor, making yellow one of our most popular doughs
  • Devil’s Food: Not too dark, this chocolate cake is light and tender
  • Half & Half: Can’t decide between yellow and chocolate? Get a layer of each!
  • White: firm dough with a pure vanilla taste
  • Marble: white & devil’s food cake batters swirled together for a random blend of vanilla and chocolate
  • Banana: real mashed bananas mixed into the batter create an authentic, moist banana dough
  • Graham Cracker: adding graham crumbs and a touch of honey to the mix develop a warm, slightly sweet taste
  • Carrot: ground carrots, chopped pecans, crushed pineapple, and a dash of spice combine for a traditional flavor
  • Angel Food: made with whipped egg whites and no yolks, this dough is very light and fluffy
  • German Chocolate: a little sweeter with a lighter chocolate flavor than devil’s food
  • Red Velvet: moist, reddish colored cake with notes of chocolate
  • Funfetti: vanilla flavored white cake mixed with multi-sprinkles

Cake Options: Fillings

When choosing your flavors, please note that cakes with Basic, Preserve, and Flavor Blend fillings are the easiest to cut and serve. We recommend a long, sharp, clean serrated knife and to avoid cutting thin slices. Even if this doesn’t work— don’t worry— the taste is great, and you’ve now created a trifle-like dessert.

Our two layer sheet cakes have 1 filling layer, three layer sheet cakes have 2 filling layers, and round cakes have 2-3 filling layers. See our filling options below:


  • Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Fudge
  • Whipped Cream (requires refrigeration)
  • Chocolate Whipped Cream (requires refrigeration)
  • Whipped Cream & Buttercream Flavor Blends (see flavors below)
  • Custard (requires refrigeration)
  • Chocolate Custard (requires refrigeration)

Fresh Fruit

These fillings require refrigeration

  • Fresh Strawberry (availability varies, particularly in November & December)
  • Banana
  • Crushed Pineapple


  • Apricot
  • Pineapple
  • Raspberry
  • Strawberry

Flavor Blends

  • Apricot Cream
  • Blueberry Cream
  • Caramel Cream
  • Cherry Cream
  • Cocoa Cream
  • Chocolate Marshmallow Cream
  • Creme de Menthe Cream (alcohol-free)
  • Hazelnut Cream
  • Irish Cream (alcohol-free)
  • Lemon Cream
  • Marshmallow Cream
  • Mocha
  • Peppermint Cream
  • Raspberry Cream
  • Strawberry Cream
  • Walnut Cream

Other Fruit and Fillings

These fillings require refrigeration

  • "Frozen" Strawberry: Scratch-Made Strawberry Pie Filling
  • "Frozen" Cherry: Scratch-Made Cherry Pie Filling
  • Crushed Pineapple
  • Cannoli
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • Cream Cheese
  • German Chocolate (sweet, caramel-like texture with coconut and pecans)
  • Lemon
  • Cookies 'n' Cream

An Extra European Touch

Add liqueur to your cake layers for an extra burst of flavor. These options are especially delicious when blended with whipped cream:

  • Rum
  • Kahlua
  • Amaretto
  • Chambord
  • Kirschwasser
  • Baileys

Cake Options: Icing

When it comes to decorated cakes, the outside is just as important as the inside. We offer several options so you’re guaranteed to find the perfect icing to pair with your cake and filling. Our frosting varieties include the following:

  • Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Whipped Cream (requires refrigeration)
  • Chocolate Whipped Cream (requires refrigeration)
  • Fudge
  • Poured Ganache (cake must be iced in buttercream or chocolate buttercream first)
  • Cream Cheese (requires refrigeration)
  • Rolled Fondant

Coconut Cake Crunch

Our homemade Coconut Cake Crunch is used on banded whipped cream iced cakes, as well as large buttercream iced sheet cakes. It has a slightly sweet coconut flavor and adds a bit of texture to the cake. For those concerned about allergens, cake crunch may contain trace amounts of nuts. Substitutions are available so please inquire about alternatives if you have allergy or taste concerns.

Decisions, Decisions

Unsure what cakes pair well with what fillings? Want to change up your usual flavors for something different? Check out our Employee Favorites for tried and true suggestions from the experts!