Ordering Your Cookies

Looking for a unique gift or hosting a function? Give your guests an irresistible bite-sized treat with Jarosch Bakery butter cookie boxes and trays! We hand decorate each of these tasty and colorful cookies with colored chocolate, sprinkles, and nuts while others are sandwiched with chocolate, strawberry, raspberry, or apricot fruit preserves.

Priced by the pound, order as many or as few cookies as you want while you pick out your favorites or let us choose the assortment. We require advanced notice for custom assortments. Butter cookies are available in the following sizes and servings:

1 Pound: Serves 8 - 10
2 Pounds: Serves 16 - 20
3 Pounds: Serves 24 - 30
4 Pounds: Serves 32 - 40
5 Pounds: Serves 40 - 50

For Thanksgiving and Christmas:

This December 2021, Butter Cookies are ONLY AVAILABLE in 3 Types of Assortments:

Full Assortments, No-Nut Assortments, and Non-Christmas Assortments

There is no pre-ordering of or coming to the store and picking out specific cookie types. To avoid the long waits closer to the Christmas, we highly recommend picking up your cookies a couple weeks early and freezing them until Christmas. It works - we've tried it! We'll happily shrink wrap your boxes for you, as well!

Check out our year-round selection (some varieties not available)

Currently unavailable: Raspberry Sandwich, Chocolate Sandwich, Apricot Sandwich, Brownie

Custom Cookies

Due to the current demand for iced cookies, RESTRICTIONS have been made on cookies with certain designs and shapes. Please call for current guidelines

Whether you’re planning a baby shower or want memorable wedding favors, you can add a sweet touch to your next event with Jarosch Bakery custom cookies. If you're giving cookies as gifts or favors, save time by letting us wrap them for you! We offer a few options at additional costs. We generally require two weeks notice for custom cookie orders; however, if you have a time constraint, give us a call and we can discuss options. Prices vary based on design requests.

Custom Cookie Gallery

Our customers are always bringing us interesting designs for fun & memorable cookies! Here's a selection of unique designs from our portfolio to inspire you! Custom cookies do have minimums depending on the style so call us for more info.