Butter Cookies • Large Cookies • Custom Cookies

Famous Handmade Butter Cookies

Voted “Best Cookies” by the readers of the Daily Herald, Jarosch Bakery is renowned for our melt-in your-mouth butter cookies. Whether you’re giving a box as a gift or serving trays of these delicate treats at a banquet, we offer 25 varieties of these scratch made cookies your guests can enjoy!

Butter Cookies
Butter Cookie Tray

Ordering Your Cookies

Looking for a unique gift or hosting a function? Give your guests an irresistible bite-sized treat with Jarosch Bakery butter cookie boxes and trays! We hand decorate each of these tasty and colorful cookies with colored chocolate, sprinkles, and nuts while others are sandwiched with chocolate, strawberry, raspberry, or apricot fruit preserves.

Priced by the pound, order as many or as few cookies as you want while you pick out your favorites or let us choose the assortment. We require advanced notice for custom assortments. Butter cookies are available in the following sizes and servings:

  • 1 Pound: Serves 8 - 10
  • 2 Pounds: Serves 16 - 20
  • 2.5 Pounds: Serves 22 - 24
  • 3 Pounds: Serves 24 - 30
  • 4 Pounds: Serves 32 - 40
  • 5 Pounds: Serves 40 - 50


Between Thanksgiving and Christmas:

We only accept Butter Cookie Pre-Orders for 3 Types of Assortments:

Full Assortments, No-Nut Assortments, and Non-Christmas Assortments

There is no pre-ordering of specific cookie types. If you would like certain kinds of butter cookies, we invite you to come to the bakery between November 26th - December 14th and we'll pack up all of your favorites while you wait! We'll happily shrink wrap your boxes, and we highly recommend freezing them until Christmas. It works - we've tried it! Give us a call if you have any questions - our friendly staff is happy to help!

Check out our year-round selection below:

Butter Cookie Chart
Butter Cookie Chart 2

Classic Large Cookies

Nothing beats scratch-made cookies with a homemade taste reminiscent of the ones Grandma used to bake. From chocolate chip to oatmeal raisin, you’ll love Jarosch Bakery’s delicious assortments of traditional cookies. Our large cookies are sold individually, available year round, and measure about 3" to 4” in diameter.

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Chocolate Chip Cookies

Sweet & Crunchy traditional cookies

Sugar Cookie

Sugar Cookies

Buttery cookies covered in sugar

Cranberry Oatmeal Cookie 2020

Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies

Oatmeal cookies with cinnamon, dried cranberries, & white chocolate

Smiley Face Cookie

Face Cookies

Sugar cookie dipped in melted yellow fondant with a chocolate fondant face

Sprinkle Cookie

Sprinkle Cookies

Sugar Cookie covered in sprinkles. Colors vary depending on the season

Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie

Chocolate Sprinkle Cookies

Sugar cookies covered in classic chocolate sprinkles

Butter Jumble Cookie - Sprinkle

Butter Jumbles

Buttery, delicate cookie dough with 3 flavor options: Plain, Sprinkles, & Chocolate Sprinkles

Custom Cookies

Whether you’re planning a baby shower or want memorable wedding favors, you can add a sweet touch to your next event with Jarosch Bakery custom cookies. Decorative cookies can be customized with various shapes and designs, from names & numbers to pirate faces and monsters. For corporate events, we can pipe on your company logo with fondant icing or scan it as an edible image onto our sugar cookie.

If you're giving cookies as gifts or favors, save time by letting us wrap them for you! We offer a few options at additional costs. We generally require two weeks notice for custom cookie orders; however, if you have a time constraint, give us a call and we can discuss options. Prices vary based on design requests.

Custom Cookie Gallery

Our customers are always bringing us interesting designs for fun & memorable cookies! Here's a selection of popular styles and unique designs from our portfolio to inspire you! Custom cookies do have minimums depending on the style so call us for more info.

Bridal Shower & Wedding Cookies

Even More Cookies

Birthday Cookies
Kids Party Cookies
Baby Shower Cookies
Sports Cookies

Contact us in Elk Grove Village, Illinois, to discover for yourself the addictive power of our hand-made butter cookies! We proudly accept orders for cookie trays from customers throughout the Chicago Metro area, as well as all over the country.